Why Hiring a Social Media Manager Didn’t Work the First Time

If you’ve hired a social media manager before and felt disappointed, frustrated, or underwhelmed — you’re not alone.

Most of the time, when a hire doesn’t work out, it’s not because social media doesn’t work. It’s because the role was misunderstood, expectations were misaligned, or strategy was missing from the start.

Here’s why hiring a social media manager often doesn’t work the first time — and what actually needs to be different for it to succeed.

1. You Hired for Execution, Not Strategy

This is the most common issue.

Many businesses hire a social media manager to:

• post consistently

• create captions

• “handle Instagram”

But posting is execution.

Without a clear strategy, a social media manager is left guessing:

• what content matters

• who the audience actually is

• what success looks like

When strategy is missing, even the best execution feels ineffective.

2. The Goals Were Never Clear

If the goal was simply “more engagement” or “to be more active,” the results were always going to feel vague.

Before social media can work, there needs to be clarity around:

• what the business wants from social media

• how it supports revenue, bookings, or growth

• what metrics actually matter

Without this, it becomes hard to measure success and easy to feel like nothing is working.

3. You Expected Social Media to Fix Bigger Problems

Social media can amplify what already exists but it can’t compensate for:

• unclear branding

• inconsistent offerings

• weak messaging

• lack of differentiation

When those pieces aren’t in place, social media feels like effort without payoff. The hire ends up carrying expectations that no content strategy alone can fix.

4. There Wasn’t Enough Collaboration

Strong social media results come from collaboration, not handoff.

If the process felt like:

“Here, take this and run with it,”

the outcome often feels disconnected from the brand.

The most effective partnerships include:

• feedback loops

• shared understanding of the business

• alignment on tone and priorities

Without this, content can feel technically fine, but emotionally off.

5. The Role Was Never Clearly Defined

“Social media manager” can mean very different things.

Some focus on:

• community management

• content scheduling

• analytics

Others focus on:

• content ideation

• strategy

• brand positioning

When the role isn’t clearly defined, expectations don’t match deliverables, and both sides leave feeling unsatisfied.

What Actually Needs to Be Different

When social media does work, the difference usually comes down to this:

Strategy comes first

Before posting, there’s clarity around:

• audience

• positioning

• messaging

• goals

Execution supports the strategy

Content has a purpose. Each post plays a role.

Expectations are aligned

Everyone understands:

• what social media can realistically do

• what it can’t

• how long results take

When these pieces are in place, hiring support feels less like a gamble and more like a partnership.

Final Thought

If hiring a social media manager didn’t work the first time, it doesn’t mean you made a mistake.

It usually means the foundation wasn’t ready yet.

With the right strategy, structure, and alignment, social media becomes a tool that supports growth, not a task that drains time and energy.

Considering Hiring Again?

I work with lifestyle, and service-based businesses to build social media strategies before execution — so support actually works.

→ Submit an inquiry
→ Subscribe to my strategy notes